David Hewlett's Choice for Best Episode of Stargate Atlantis is Truly Insightful
Unraveling the Emotional Depths of McKay's Character
Spoiler Alert: The following discussion reveals crucial plot points from Season 5, Episode 6 of "Stargate Atlantis."
When we think of steadfast characters throughout the five seasons of "Stargate Atlantis," Dr. Rodney McKay, portrayed by David Hewlett, undoubtedly comes to mind. McKay's exceptional skills as an astrophysicist have been nothing short of vital for the team aboard Atlantis, particularly when they face complex challenges that seem insurmountable. However, the flip side of having such an intelligent individual on your team is the potential for his notorious condescension. McKay often humiliates team members whom he perceives as lesser in intellect, displaying a flair for sarcasm and irritation when problems arise. Yet, despite these personal quirks, his character is indispensable; behind his self-centered bravado lies a genuine willingness to protect those in peril and even risk his own safety for his teammates.
As "Stargate Atlantis" reached its fifth and final season, the show aimed to tie up character arcs thoughtfully (source) and spotlight various crew members to raise the stakes in their adventures. In a discussion with GateWorld, Hewlett revealed that his favorite script from the series—fittingly, an episode from this concluding season—focused heavily on his character:
"The script I hold dear is 'The Shrine of Talus,' written by Brad Wright. This script is extraordinary; it will absolutely astonish everyone. It offers a phenomenal acting opportunity, and I can’t wait for people to see it. Importantly, it features my sister, Kate Hewlett, returning as Jeannie. It's going to be a very emotional episode, no doubt about that. McKay faces severe challenges involving his health, a personal struggle that I've been eagerly anticipating."
For those who may not be aware, 'The Shrine' is the sixth episode of the final season and revolves around McKay grappling with a life-threatening infectious disease. Hewlett’s comments about the script were not unfounded; "The Shrine" offers viewers a captivating look at McKay’s character depth as portrayed through Hewlett's incredible performance. Let's dive deeper into what makes this episode so unforgettable.
A Heartfelt Performance by Hewlett that Reshapes McKay's Narrative
The episode begins with Dr. Keller, played by Jewel Staite, documenting McKay’s condition, as he suffers from an illness called Second Childhood, which causes him to lose his memory rapidly. This disturbing condition strips McKay of his identity and accomplishments, creating deep anxiety among those around him. It's a striking transformation to witness McKay, normally so assured, become increasingly vulnerable, as the disease begins to wipe away not only his memories but also the qualities that shape how we see him. It is at this point that we are introduced to his sister Jeannie, portrayed by Kate Hewlett (source), as the team recognizes the urgency of letting her say goodbye to her brother, who is deteriorating rapidly.
Hewlett's skillful portrayal of McKay as he traverses the emotional landscape of memory loss adds immeasurable depth to "The Shrine." Rather than simply portraying McKay as a stereotype of a pretentious genius, Hewlett captures his character’s vulnerabilities, showcasing a man who teeters on the brink of losing not just his memories, but the very essence of who he is. In McKay's interactions, particularly with Dr. Keller, there’s a rawness that transcends usual character tropes, revealing both his frailty and his unresolved feelings.
The storyline expertly intertwines these personal elements with a quest to find salvation at the titular shrine on the planet Talus, which was previously explored by Ronon Dex, characterized by Jason Momoa. Venturing there becomes a desperate attempt to save McKay, one that the crew is willing to undertake even as they face daunting risks from a fortified enemy outpost.
Ultimately, "The Shrine" exceeds expectations, giving fans a poignant glimpse into McKay's character that ignites nostalgia for his sharp wit and bristly demeanor. The heartbreaking repercussions of unexpected memory loss echo deeply, prompting the team to confront the painful truth that life is transient, and all relationships have their limits.
What are your thoughts? Does McKay’s journey in 'The Shrine' resonate with you? How do you feel about his character’s evolution throughout the series? Join the conversation in the comments below!
And remember, how we remember and honor our loved ones can shape who we become.
